Knots of Friends – or not

Regular readers know that we recently returned from a trip that started in Buenos Aires and included a cruise around Cape Horn following Dr. Bob Carson, professor of geology at Whitman, who lectured about the region and led hikes: during, pre, and post.  There were almost a hundred of us from the Walla Walla area.  What surprised me was how little mixing there was between and among the Walla Walla crowd.
You would think that a hundred of us from the same town would mix, mingle, and get to know each other better during two weeks on a ship carrying thirteen hundred passengers.  That didn’t happen.  Small knots of friends stuck together.  Casual acquaintances greeted each other but tended to pass on.  Making an effort to meet someone new often ran into a polite boundary that said, in essence, “I don’t know you back home, why are you greeting me here?”  It was’t meant in a snobbish way.  It was more out of surprise at being greeted unexpectedly.  It seemed that names and faces were soon forgotten even when introductions were made.  Dianna, my wife, has an excellent memory for faces.  Once she meets someone, that’s it: she never forgets.  Both on the trip and after, she would see someone she had met, give them a friendly greeting and ask about the trip.  A common response has been a blank stare of no recognition. 
This from people who are residents of a small city once crowned The Friendliest Town in America.
So what was going on?
Well, let me speak for myself.  We didn’t go to Buenos Aires as a group.  Each of us had our own travel plans.  As for us, we were coming from Maui, and it was a long, long flight from there to Seattle to Houston to Buenos Aires.  Nevertheless, we were assured that someone would meet us.  Wandering around outside customs looking for whoever that was, I was relieved to spot people I knew back home.  A little knot of old friends is a powerful social magnet.  “I don’t know where I am and don’t understand what’s going on, but there are my friends.  I’ll start there.”  
We’ve traveled around the globe, and have never had much trouble finding our way.  I could have done the same with any group of equally confused tourists.  One time in China we managed our confusion with the help of a couple of Chinese equally confused with us.  It can be done, but our little band of a hundred wasn’t made up of strangers.  It was made up of knots of friends and acquaintances.  Our knots were people with whom I looked forward to sharing the adventures that lay ahead, adventures we would talk about for years to come.  It wasn’t intended to exclude anyone else, but it leaned in that direction.
And that’s what tended to happen throughout the trip.  Who got left out were people who were not a part of any particular knot of friends and acquaintances, and what a shame that was.  The thing is, we really are a friendly community.  Our group of a hundred was undoubtedly among the most friendly.  Experience indicates that it isn’t hard to break into a group, or make new friends, and strangers are warmly welcomed by most.  The problem is that it takes some initiative by the one who is not in a knot, and that takes an enormous amount of social courage, more than many of us have.
We were invited to an on board cocktail reception that did not include anyone from our group.  I spotted a couple not talking to anyone, so I went over to introduce myself and see if I could get a knot going.  They assumed I was part of the ship’s staff because I took the initiative to introduce myself and ask about them.  They told me they were from a place in northern England, were sure they were the only Brits on the ship, and felt a little lonely.  I pointed out a gaggle of Brits not ten feet away, and not just Brits, but from the same region.  I knew that because the larger group had welcomed me into their knot not long before.  Later on I noticed the couple tentatively edging their way toward them, but not seeing an easy opening in the circle they retreated to a corner by themselves.  Social courage is hard to come by.  The fear of rejection is deep in each of us.  I know.  At heart I’m a shy, introverted person.
Social awareness of what is going on around us appears to be hard to come by also.  How hard can it be to sense a person hovering near by who wants to be noticed and included, but is reluctant to butt in?
What struck me is that what happened on our trip is the same thing that happens in congregations all across the country Sunday after Sunday.  We proclaim ourselves to be churches where everyone is welcome.  We work hard to recruit greeters and guides of one kind or another.  It works for a short time, and then it’s back to knots of friends visiting with each other and ignoring those who are not in a knot.  It’s not intentional.  It just happens.  Now and then someone has the courage to break in, but not often.  Now and then a congregation is blessed with someone like my wife who recognizes the stranger, enjoys the prospect of meeting him or her, and never forgets a face or name.  We could use more like her.  I work on it, but not always that well. 

What’s the solution?  I don’t know.  Maybe you do.  If so, let’s have it.  If you want to leave a comment you have to log on through  I don’t know why.  That’s just the way it works.

4 thoughts on “Knots of Friends – or not”

  1. There's friendly and being open to new friends. I find Walla Wallans a fairly friendly bunch, but I don't find them particularly open to new friends. Most folks seem to have their dance cards already full so unless you're willing to audition on an almost constant basis, or you are perceived as being someone really, really special (i.e. rich, influential, a \”celebrity\” of some sort, etc.), it's a tough crowd. Best,Mickey Goodson

  2. Perhaps because I'm clergy, neither I nor my wife ever faced that problem. At the same time we never bought into the myth that you had to have been born here to be accepted. It's the story told in every town and small city, and it gets old very quickly. It's colorful, and like any myth has a grain of truth in it, but a grain is a small thing. A quick study of power and influence networks is all that is needed to reveal its thin veneer in almost every place. On the other hand, people who buy into it live into it. The key, I think, is to not care very much about it, and just get on with life and making friends. Nothing bugs a would be keeper of the social register more than stumbling onto someone who doesn't care very much one way or the other. Having said that, I'm fascinated by the interwoven family relationships in places such as WW, and deeply admire the stories of pioneer struggles. They have produced outstanding citizens, and a lot of just plain good people worthy of respect and admiration.

  3. Let me add a post script: I don't have many friends. I have many acquaintances, some casual and some more intimate. Friends are unique creatures who come into one's life a few at a time. Some stay for a season, and some for a lifetime.

Leave a Reply